Leadership Insights

Two Ledgers 

Read Time:

The people most likely to be doing informal leadership work unprompted are often the people with the highest leadership potential.

The hidden leadership tax has two sets of costs. They run in parallel, and they compound each other, which is why institutions that ignore this pattern tend to stay stuck in it long after the problem is obvious.

First, we’ll explore the costs to the people carrying the tax. Then, we’ll explore the impact to the institution collecting it.

What It Costs the People Carrying It

Time is the most visible cost, but it isn’t the most significant one.

Perhaps the most important cost is what informal leadership work can crowd out. The person who spends their energy mediating conflicts, translating strategy, and holding teams together is not spending that energy on their own development, their own visibility, or their own advancement. They are investing in the institution’s functionality at the direct expense of their own path.

Capacity drains without replenishment. This kind of informal work, particularly the relational kind, is depleting in ways that task work often isn’t. When it accumulates without recognition or relief, the people carrying it get disillusioned as well as tired. The willingness to keep showing up for work that goes unseen does erode as time passes.

Development stalls. The skills required to do informal leadership well (like conflict navigation, cultural translation, and relational intelligence) are genuine leadership competencies. And they’re not inherently built by informal leadership. There is a significant difference between doing something a hundred times and developing mastery in it. Recognition, feedback, and intentional development are what turn repetition into growth. Without them, the tax produces exhaustion rather than expertise.

The tax doesn’t fall evenly. It’s worth naming plainly: On most campuses, informal leadership work concentrates on certain people more than others. People who are socially conditioned to absorb relational labor, who feel the pull of institutional loyalty most acutely, or who have learned that stepping back carries its own costs tend to carry more.

Members must be logged in to view this content.

 
 
Sophia Spotlight

How to Use Sophia as Faculty

Managing Workload

Deciding what to say yes and no to is one way to keep informal work from quietly crowding out what you actually need to prioritize, the exact pattern this week has covered. Sophia can help you sort through competing demands and plan how to talk about it with the person who can actually help.

“I’m a [rank] in [discipline]. My priorities this year are [research goals], but I’m also being asked to [teaching load, committee work, advising]. Help me decide what to say yes and no to, and how to talk about it with [department chair / mentor].”

Watch the demo video below to see this prompt in action.