Leadership Insights

When Your Feelings and Your Record Differ  

Read Time:

Make your next decision from what your track record actually shows.

A newly appointed associate dean sits in a planning meeting about an advising project that has stalled. She has an idea for how the handoffs between units could work. She has also led two similar projects to completion. However, because she feels that she has not been in the role long enough, she keeps the idea to herself, and the meeting moves on.

She had two sources of information to draw upon. One was a feeling. The other was a record. The two didn’t match, and she went with the feeling.

Consider a question worth asking: What if your record shows that you are doing this well? Many leaders have never let themselves explore that thought, and asking it can feel presumptuous. Looking at your record fairly means allowing for the answer to be yes. The record may also show a gap, and then you know what to work on first. Either way, you have more to stand on than a feeling.

A feeling is a reason to look closer. A flutter of doubt before a meeting is worth asking about, and it deserves to be taken seriously as information about how the situation feels to you. Giving a feeling its due also means placing it next to something else: a record of what you have done. If the two match, you can move ahead with more assurance. If they differ, that difference is worth understanding. Did something about this situation change, or does your record leave something out? Once you have asked those questions, the record is the stronger basis for deciding what to do. Three qualities support that weight:

  • It is specific: A feeling of being unprepared is general, and it can be hard to name which part of the work it concerns. An entry in your record names a decision, when it happened, and what came of it. Because it is specific, you can place it next to what the new work requires and see how closely the two match up.
  • Others can confirm it: A colleague who was in the room can say what happened. A feeling can be checked only by you, and it varies with your week.
  • It can be revised: New evidence can change what the record shows, so relying on it leaves room for correction.

With the record in view, the associate dean has what she needs to offer her idea. The same holds for other moments where a leader might hold back due to feeling unprepared. You can make a decision that belongs to you instead of passing it on to someone else, and you can say yes to the next opportunity.

A single look at your record is useful, but limiting. Keeping the record up to date means that the evidence is in front of you the moment you need it.

Members must be logged in to view this content.

 
 
Sophia Spotlight

How to Use Sophia as an HR Leader

Changing Culture Around Leadership

Shifting the belief that leadership belongs only to people with titles takes the same trust in your own judgment this week has covered, applied at the institutional level. Sophia can help you think through what’s driving that belief and where to start.

“At my institution, many employees believe leadership belongs to people with titles. I want to change that. Help me think through what’s driving the belief and what small, practical steps I can take to broaden how people see themselves as leaders.”

Watch the demo video below to see this prompt in action.