Most difficult employee situations on campus are handled without Human Resources, and for most situations, it’s not needed. Department chairs, directors, supervisors, and deans are able to handle performance and conduct concerns directly, which makes sense, as the people closest to the work are often the ones best positioned to address it.
However, that arrangement depends on supervisors who feel equipped to act. Many step into these roles with little supervisory training, and chairs often do so with limited formal authority over faculty employment. This means that when a concern is uncomfortable, unclear, or tied up in tenure and shared governance, difficult conversations can get postponed and the behavior in question continues. HR often becomes involved only after a pattern is established and options have narrowed, and when HR coaches a supervisor or chair, there isn’t always a shared process or language to draw upon.
The people involved in these situations are committed to doing this well. What’s missing is a common approach that supervisors, chairs, and deans can use early, and that HR can reinforce when they’re brought in. Here, we’ll look at one such framework, Jeanne Hey’s EM & EM Model, and what HR can gain from it on both the staff side and the academic side.
Why Addressing Difficult Behavior Is Harder in Higher Ed
Addressing difficult behavior is challenging in any workplace. In higher ed, those conversations are even harder to start—and harder to follow through on—for multiple reasons.
Take the department chair. Chairs are often faculty members first, who are asked to lead colleagues who were recently their peers, and who might be peers again after their term ends. They’re responsible for teaching loads, service, and conduct, but they rarely have authority over every aspect of faculty employment. Decisions about tenure, promotion, and discipline often sit with committees, deans, and provosts. A chair may know exactly what behavior needs to be addressed and still be unsure where their role begins and ends.
Then there are the structures, which exist for good reasons. Tenure protects academic freedom, and shared governance gives faculty a real voice in how the institution runs. Unions, where they exist, protect fair treatment. These values are worth defending, but they can leave a supervisor wondering whether a direct conversation is appropriate, and what could go wrong if it isn’t handled perfectly.
Add to that something that is easy to overlook: Many chairs and supervisors lean toward empathy, and that’s a strength. But it becomes a barrier when supervisors set aside the expectations their role requires out of care for a colleague. Chairs may see their role as supporting faculty, not as holding them accountable, and many have not been shown how they fit into the institution’s broader disciplinary process. Wanting to be fair and kind is the right instinct, but not having a structured way to be fair, kind, and clear at the same time is a definite issue.
The EM & EM Model
Jeanne Hey’s EM & EM Model gives supervisors a progression for addressing difficult behavior, with each step building on the one before it. The name comes from the four steps: engagement, management, enforcement, and minimization:
-
Engagement
This is where every situation starts. The supervisor names the problem clearly, listens to the employee’s perspective, sets expectations for change, and schedules a follow-up with continued support. Many situations can be resolved here, yet this is the conversation that most often gets postponed.
-
Management
This applies when engagement hasn’t resolved the concern. The supervisor restates the problem with a stronger emphasis on expectations, building on what was discussed the first time.
-
Enforcement
This comes next if performance or conduct still hasn’t changed. Expectations are paired with consequences for noncompliance, HR is involved as needed, and the supervisor develops a behavior modification plan, holds a formal meeting, and documents the process.
-
Minimization
This is reserved for situations where effective disciplinary action isn’t possible. The focus then shifts to reducing the impact of the behavior on the people around the employee.
The order of the steps is important. Supervisors start with empathy and move toward a more authoritative response over time as needed. The goal of addressing problematic behavior or performance is to understand the problem and to help the person to avoid repeating it. However, leaders sometimes move straight to “Just hold them accountable,” but in this model, counseling, feedback, and support come first, and supervisors have a defined next step when those don’t work.
Using this model requires a leader who is willing to start the conversation, and it works best when that leader has backing from a dean, a director, or HR (as that backing is where HR can make a concrete contribution).
Why HR Should Be in the Room
Learning about the model is a useful start, but it works best when people practice it. Managing Difficult Faculty & Staff is a hands-on workshop where participants work through the steps with peers, rehearse the conversations they’ve been putting off, and leave with an intervention plan for a real situation on their own campus. The workshop is designed for supervisors, chairs, and deans, and for the HR professionals who support them.
HR professionals can take away two things from the workshop: On the staff side, it’s a process HR can use and reinforce across the institution. On the academic side, it’s a clearer view into how chairs and faculty work together, and where HR can support them. The next two sections address each of these in turn.
What HR Gets for the Staff Side
On the staff side of campus, HR is often where supervisors turn when they aren’t sure what to do next. Without a shared process around addressing difficult staff, each of those conversations starts from scratch, and the advice a supervisor receives can depend on who they happen to ask.
The EM & EM model gives HR a consistent framework to coach from. Because each step has a defined purpose, HR can ask a supervisor where they are in the progression, what has already been said to the employee, and what the next step needs to accomplish. That makes coaching more consistent from one supervisor to the next, and it helps supervisors to act earlier, before a pattern forms.
Documentation is part of the process, too. The enforcement step includes a behavior modification plan, a formal meeting, and a written record of the process. When earlier steps are documented as well, the institution can demonstrate that they raised the concern, set expectations, offered support, and followed up. A clear, consistently followed process is generally easier to stand behind than an improvised one.
Some HR leaders also use the model to review their own practices. An HR director at one campus noted that the framework helped to identify gaps in the institution’s existing process.
Another HR professional described how the framework worked in practice:
“I recently attended ‘Managing Difficult Faculty & Staff,’ and it was incredibly beneficial. The framework provided a helpful way for me to break down the steps for employee management to my college leadership in a way that is both manageable and precise.”
What HR Gets for the Academic Side
Faculty relationships work differently from most staff reporting lines, and the differences aren’t always apparent to HR. A chair’s relationship with a faculty member is shaped by shared governance, by tenure, and by the fact that the chair is a colleague (and often will be again in the future).
The EM & EM model offers HR a view into that dynamic. Because the model begins with engagement, it matches how chairs tend to approach difficult situations: with empathy, and with a preference for resolving issues through conversation. The model then shows where that approach reaches its limit, and how a chair can move into clearer expectations without abandoning care for the colleague.
The model also helps chairs to see where they fit into the institution’s disciplinary process. Many chairs know that a formal process exists—but not which parts are their responsibility. When a chair understands that engagement and management are their responsibility, and that enforcement involves a dean or HR, the path from a first conversation to a formal one becomes easier to see.
For HR, this creates a bridge between employee relations priorities and leadership development. Chairs get a way to act earlier, while HR gets a common framework to reinforce when coaching them, as well as a clearer picture of what chairs can and cannot do on their own.
Where HR Can Help Close the Gap
HR doesn’t need to be involved in every difficult conversation. But HR can shape the conditions in which those conversations happen, and whether supervisors know what support is available, whether they have a process to follow, and whether asking for help early feels normal.
HR can take three practical actions toward those conditions:
- Make support visible before a case exists. On many campuses, HR and department chairs rarely connect outside of escalations. For this reason, chairs may not know what HR can offer before a situation becomes formal, while HR may not know what chairs are dealing with until it does. Regular contact with chairs, deans, and supervisors, such as a standing conversation or an orientation for new chairs, makes it more likely that someone asks for input while a concern is still small.
- Offer a shared process. When HR, chairs, and deans use the same steps and the same language, supervisors don’t have to guess what they’re allowed to do, and HR doesn’t have to rebuild its approach with each case. The EM & EM model is one way to provide that.
- Be a thought partner in the early steps. HR’s role is most visible at enforcement, which makes sense, since that is where documentation, consequences, and policy come into play. Engagement and management are where feedback and support matter most, and where a supervisor is most likely to want someone to think through how to begin. HR can offer to be that person without taking ownership of the conversation. Supervisors who get that support early therefore come to see asking for help as normal.
None of this asks HR to take on more cases. Instead, it asks HR to focus its efforts earlier, while options are still open and relationships are intact.
Questions to Take Back to Your Campus
A good place to start is with a few questions about the conditions on your campus:
- Do supervisors and chairs know what support HR offers before a situation becomes formal, and how to ask for it?
- Do chairs know the discipline process and which parts of it are theirs?
- When HR coaches a supervisor, are HR, deans, and chairs working from a common language, or are they starting over each time?
- How often do HR and academic leaders talk before a case exists?
If the answers point to gaps, Managing Difficult Faculty & Staff is one way to start closing them. We encourage HR to attend alongside the chairs, deans, and supervisors they support, so that everyone leaves with the same framework and language.
