Do the USNWR Rankings Limit Innovation in Higher Education?
Last month I had the pleasure of speaking with Dr. Ricardo Azziz, former president of Georgia Regents University, about the US News and World Report (USNWR) higher education rankings. The conversation is especially timely as millions of students and parents are knee deep in the college application season this fall. In our conversation we explored many inherent flaws with the rankings system – but in talking with a former college president, I was particularly interested in exploring how the importance and visibility of these rankings affect how university leaders make decisions. Do the rankings support the innovation and change needed in higher education or do they actually hinder our ability to take risks and try new things? Our conversation was wide-ranging, and we uncovered important insights for boards of trustees, policymakers, and university leaders. In the end, we concluded that the rankings do indeed inhibit innovation in higher education. This happens because the rankings: 1. Credit for Spending More, Not Doing More With Less 10% of an institution’s score in the rankings is driven directly by the amount of resources spent per student. An additional 20% of the score is driven by “faculty resources,” which includes items like the proportion […]
