Closing the Gap Between HR and the People Who Manage Difficult Situations First  

Most difficult employee situations on campus are handled without Human Resources, and for most situations, it’s not needed. Department chairs, directors, supervisors, and deans are able to handle performance and conduct concerns directly, which makes sense, as the people closest to the work are often the ones best positioned to address it. However, that arrangement depends on supervisors who feel equipped to act. Many step into these roles with little supervisory training, and chairs often do so with limited formal authority over faculty employment. This means that when a concern is uncomfortable, unclear, or tied up in tenure and shared governance, difficult conversations can get postponed and the behavior in question continues. HR often becomes involved only after a pattern is established and options have narrowed, and when HR coaches a supervisor or chair, there isn’t always a shared process or language to draw upon. The people involved in these situations are committed to doing this well. What’s missing is a common approach that supervisors, chairs, and deans can use early, and that HR can reinforce when they’re brought in. Here, we’ll look at one such framework, Jeanne Hey’s EM & EM Model, and what HR can gain from it […]